article picture

Falling for Vertigo’s Madeleine

by Jesse Warr

If five years ago I‘d not visited the town of San Juan Bautista, there‘d be no guided Vertigo tour. Most people go there as fourth-graders to see the old Spanish mission, the stable, and associated buildings--a field trip during their year of California History. As a tour operator, I went out of idle curiosity.

I love the town because it appears to have no aspirations to fame. (Search in vain for a “San Juan Bautista” T-shirt.) But what a unique place! Its mission church sits adjacent to the San Andreas fault. Stand next to its Indian cemetery on a rise above the old El Camino Real to view miles of cultivated fields stretching across the Salinas Valley to the Gabilan Range. Face west to see the Castro adobe, where the Breen family, survivors of the Donner Party, took refuge with the Mexican authority; Breen descendants still hold public office in the county. There’s a saloon straight out of the Old West, the original land office still selling real estate, and antique shops along main street known throughout the region. San Juan Bautista is also the home of El Teatro Campesino, whose Zoot Suit went on to national acclaim.

But I believed that no potential customer would ask to be taken two hours south from San Francisco to San Juan Bautista. So I considered another tack. Other than fourth-graders, San Juan Bautista is best known to legion of fans of Hitchcock’s classic film Vertigo. Two critical scenes were filmed here, though the thing most come to see is not there: the bell tower from which two women fall to their deaths. Not there in ‘57, or today, the fatal tower was re-created on a sound stage.

The full-day version of my tour covers most of the surviving Vertigo sites. (Ernie’s, Hitchcock’s favorite restaurant--where Scottie (James Stewart) first sees Madeleine (Kim Novak)--sadly, does not survive. After a morning of traveling to and exploring the historic plaza of San Juan Bautista, we stop for lunch under redwoods in Scotts Valley, because the Hitchcocks summered there for 32 years. Then back in San Francisco, we pay homage to Carlotta Valdez--“the beautiful Carlotta, the sad Carlotta”--at her gravesite in the Mission Dolores cemetery. She’s not here...never was. But it makes for an enchanted beginning to Scottie’s pursuit of Madeleine.

Yet we don’t spend the day looking for things that don’t exist. A remarkable number of sites are still here to be explored: the Palace of Fine Arts, the sanatorium where Scotty has his unsettling flashbacks, Scotty’s apartment below the Crookedest Street, Madeleine’s next to the Fairmont, Judy’s in the then Empire, now York Hotel, the Flood mansion atop Nob Hill, and the Palace of the Legion of Honor...alas, Carlotta is not here either. Aficionados often love most the spot at Fort Point where a possessed Madeleine jumps into the Bay. Cinephiles appreciate that Hitchcock ingeniously used mysterious, elusive San Francisco as a main character in the film--perhaps its brightest star.

City Guide and former Management Board member Jesse Warr is owner of A Friend in Town. See toursanfranciscobay.com/

All historic photos in this issue reprinted with permission, SF History Center, SF Public Library.

article picture

Hitchcock fans continue to seek out the fictional gravesite of Carlotta Valdez at the Mission Dolores cemetery, shown here in a photo taken sometime between 1870 and 1890.

article picture

Ernie’s Restaurant provided the romantic setting where Scottie first glimpsed Madeleine.

Send comments and questions to guidelines@sfcityguides.org
Material of San Francisco City Guides. Please give credit to the author and SF City Guides if referenced or reproduced.