article picture

Big Onion Walking

by Chuck Schwartz

Before heading east recently for a week in New York City, I conducted an Internet search for NYC walks and came across Big Onion Walking Tours. I have taken walking tours in Los Angeles, New York, Chicago, and London and am always looking for new ones to help me experience cities my favorite way: by walking neighborhoods and hearing interesting stories.

Big Onion started in 1991 as way to provide supplemental income for graduate students. The Big Onion website describes their guides as “the finest group of tour guides in the city. We are not your traditional tour guides. Most of us are full-time graduate students researching and writing doctoral dissertations in history. Big Onion guides have high school or college teaching experience and are quite often researching topics relevant to the tours they are leading.”

One tour is offered each day, Monday through Thursday. Two or three tours are offered on Fridays and week-ends.

Tours are “show-up” walks and cost $15 per walker, which is collected at the start of the tour. I took the "Official" Gangs of New York tour and Brooklyn Bridge & Brooklyn Heights tour. Both walks met near New York City Hall, with easy access from public transportation. Two guides were present for each tour. After payment was collected, the guides split the walkers into two equal-sized groups of about 15 walkers each. Minimal time was spent describing Big Onion, so named because its tours aim to peel away the layers of the city.

The guide for the Gangs of New York walk recently received her PhD in American Studies from NYU. Her dissertation was on Irish immigration to Yonkers from earliest times to now. Her walk took an Irish perspective and focused on the life and challenges of the Irish immigrant community. The specific blocks that were central to her tour (Five Points) were at one time so crime-infested that the whole neighborhood was demolished and replaced with law and justice buildings. Our guide did a great job of storytelling, helping the walkers envision the conditions of the era.

The Brooklyn Bridge & Brooklyn Heights walk was led by a grad student working on a Masters in English. He spoke well of the history of the Brooklyn Bridge and was able to draw upon his literature background to provide extra color and quotes as we walked through Brooklyn Heights, which was at various times the home of Walt Whitman, Truman Capote, and Arthur Miller.

The guides I had were well prepared, knowledgeable, and good speakers. Both used notebooks with historic photos. San Francisco City Guides compares favorably to Big Onion.

Newly minted City Guide Chuck Schwartz, pictured on the previous page with his wife, Debbie, in front of the Brooklyn Bridge, won the award for attending the most City Guides tours during the training class–a total of 19!



Photo courtesy of Chuck Schwartz

article picture


Send comments and questions to guidelines@sfcityguides.org
Material of San Francisco City Guides. Please give credit to the author and SF City Guides if referenced or reproduced.